Friday, February 27, 2015


Too late; the bar has been lowered


Thank goodness National Football League player contracts are not multi year. In actuality, they are a series of one-year contracts spread over a specific period of time.

For example, the three-year contract veteran quarterback Josh McCown agreed to with the Browns Friday can be terminated at any time because the money is guaranteed one year at a time.

If McCown, 36 in July, lasts all three years in Cleveland, it will be a major miracle. The fact the Browns outbid the Buffalo Bills for his services is somewhat of a minor miracle.

In so doing, Murphy’s Law paid yet another in a long line of visits to Berea Friday. The Browns have taken a muddied situation at the position and made it muddier.

McCown supposedly is going to be the wizened head who will help straighten out Johnny Manziel, Connor Shaw and whomever the Browns select in the college draft in April.

He reportedly is going to be the mentor for one quarterback who has more troubles off the field than on; another who has practice squad talent; and a third whose name we don’t know yet.

Why don’t the Browns just make him the quarterbacks coach? Oh, wait. That’s right. They already have a quarterbacks coach. They just hired 30-year-old Kevin O’Connell to mentor the quarterbacks.

So where does that leave McCown, who makes Cleveland the seventh stop in his tour through the NFL? Will he sort of assist O’Connell in helping new offensive coordinator John DeFilippo install yet another new offensive scheme? Be kind of a player/assistant coach? Is that why the Browns brought him in?

Does that mean he won’t play in regular-season games? Does that mean he won’t have a chance to beat out Manziel, Shaw or whomever for the starting job? Can we assume that no matter what happens in training camp and exhibition games, he’ll be holding a clipboard on opening day this season?

Way too many questions that shouldn’t be arising at this time of the year. Here’s another: What if McCown is clearly the best quarterback in camp? Right now, he is the best quarterback on the roster, which isn’t really saying very much at all. Not exactly something about which to brag.

It is hard to imagine Manziel, Shaw or whomever playing well enough to beat out McCown. It’s also not unreasonable to assume Mike Pettine plays the quarterback who gives the Browns the best chance to win. If McCown is that guy, what does that say about the position?

In a league that has become quarterback-driven, the Browns have taken a gigantic plunge toward the bottom of the NFL quarterbacks barrel.

To be honest, I much rather would have preferred the Browns smoke the peace pipe with Brian Hoyer and bring him back. At least we know what he can do with marginal talent on that side of the ball.

With some intelligent selecting in the college draft by General Manager Ray Farmer, the talent level on offense will improve. But with the McCown signing, the likelihood of a Hoyer return is remote at best.

It will be interesting to see how Farmer, Pettine and – we should all hope – loose lips Jimmy Haslam III explain the reasoning behind their latest signing. The spin that permeates the room should be dizzying.

15 comments:

  1. U need to get on Prozac and get over yourself.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Well Rich, I guess you didn't like the idea of bringing in Gary Danielson to mentor Bernie either?

      Delete
    2. Good one, Tim.

      Delete
    3. Good analogy, Southie, except for one point. Who on the current Browns roster is Bernie Kosar?
      And don't say Manziel.

      Delete
    4. We're still looking for the next "Bernie", but at least we have the mentor. Gotta start somewhere. Don't tell me you've lost faith in your boy Johnny?

      Delete
  2. I never had much faith to begin with. I had to see to believe and I didn't see enough in which to believe. And I don't think McCown will be as good a mentor as O'Connell. Isn't that what they hired him for? McCown is there to start in the event Manziel and whoever fail. You don't sign a guy for $5 million per to mentor.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I think you got it backwards. McCown is there to start (and mentor) until Manziel or whoever they decide on is ready, not as a backup in case of failure. Yeah, O'Connell is the QB coach but he can't provide that immediate on-the-field perspective that McCown will, not to mention his locker room presence, which is supposed to be very good.

      Delete
  3. Sounds as though you are buying this nonsense. Good locker room presence -- what the hell does that mean? Sounds like something the Browns' PR machine cranked out. How good was his presence in Tampa or the other six stops he's made in his 12 seasons?

    Just don't be too unhappy when the Browns have trouble winning five games this season. And don't get too comfortable with McCown. He won't be with this team next season.

    I wouldn't be surprised if you are one of his harshest critics when they play the games for real. There's a reason he has never been a quality quarterback. You're about to find out that reason.

    One more thing: Why can't O'Connell provide on-the-field perspective? That's part of his job. Why else would the Browns hire him? If he can't, get rid of him.

    ReplyDelete
  4. He's a QB coach, not an active player. Big difference. Whole different perspective than actually being in the middle of the action instead of watching from the sideline. Manziel found that out real quick. Why don't you wait until the next QB is added(and there will be another) before you rush to judgement? You need to ask Lane about locker room presence, he's the one that listed it as one of McCown's assets.

    ReplyDelete
  5. So tell me, what is your perception of locker room presence? Never mind what anybody else says. I want to know what you think. What exactly is locker room presence?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. A seasoned veteran willing to acclimate to his new team and surroundings while sharing his 13 years of experience with the younger players(think Dansby/Whitner). One who knows his role and accepts it, as opposed to Hoyer. Also becomes an integral part of the social interaction of the locker room.

      Delete
  6. For someone who has been with now seven teams in 13 years, that is always the gravitas he brings. If he is such a positive locker room presence, how come he hasn't been able to stick around in one place for long? I want more than locker room presence from someone making 5 mil a year.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Besides, Dansby and Whitner are players and playmakers. It's understandable young players would listen to them and follow them. McCown is playing with his seventh team in 13 seasons. What kind of sage advice can a journeyman like him provide?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Lane said it best: "3. It's not a simple black and white scenario when talking about a veteran player that can and will advise younger players and take the time to show them how to be a professional -- how to study, how to handle themselves and how to properly compete. While a coach can tell a player how to do those things, a guy in the locker room that communicates and is trusted carries more weight than a coach barking commands. McCown is a place-holder unless he comes out and tears it up."
      Argue with him. I'm tired of trying to make a point that goes ignored over and over again.

      Delete
  8. I'm not going to argue with him. I just don't agree with him. He is entitled to his opinion as are you and I. You choose to go along with him. We just don't see eye to eye. Nothing wrong with that, although I'm not sure you agree with that notion.

    ReplyDelete