Thursday, August 30, 2012
Tuesday, August 28, 2012
Puzzling and baffling
Well, that didn’t take very long.
Pat Shurmur has declared that Brandon Weeden is ready to
start the 2012 season and will not play in Thursday night’s final exhibition
game against the Chicago Bears in Cleveland.
How ready? “I think he’s very prepared,” said the Browns
head coach of his rookie quarterback . “I think he’s had an outstanding
(training) camp. I thought he had an outstanding offseason and really he’s kind
of improved every day. So for a guy that’s going through that for the first
time as a pro, I think he’s ready.”
Outstanding training camp? In what way? Outstanding
offseason? Really? Completing less than 50% of his passes is outstanding? No
touchdown passes outstanding? Is he serious? Three fumbles and four sacks in
three games are outstanding? C’mon.
Weeden is ready, all right. He’s ready to be led to the
slaughter, figuratively speaking. He’s not anywhere close to being ready for
the regular season.
For Shurmur to blow that kind of smoke at Browns fans is
somewhat insulting. I’d like to think the pure football fans of this team, not
the sycophants who will believe anything the coach says, those who understand
the game know Weeden is ill prepared for what awaits.
Colt McCoy will start and play the better part of the first
half against the Bears with Seneca Wallace and Thad Lewis dividing the
remainder of the game.
The big news here is whether McCoy or Wallace will back up
Weeden. McCoy has played very well thus far in the exhibitions and Shurmur has
been effusive in his praise for the third-year pro.
If the Browns are intent on moving McCoy, Thursday night’s
game against the Bears will serve as a showcase for other teams looking for
help at the position. Then again, if McCoy continues to play well, the Browns
might decide to keep him no matter how well Wallace plays.
It’s an interesting situation that probably causes McCoy to
wonder what he has to do to get away from Cleveland because he knows Weeden is
the man and holding a clipboard is in his immediate future.
Weeden, on the other hand, must feel awfully good when he
hears his head coach speak in such glowing terms about him. The danger there,
however, is all that praise does is give him a false sense of security.
Now I think Weeden should be the club’s starting
quarterback. But by limiting his reps in the practice games, Shurmur and
offensive coordinator Brad Childress have done him a disservice.
When Weeden lines up under center against the Philadelphia
Eagles on Sept. 9 at Cleveland Browns Stadium, the speed and quickness of the
game he sees will be nowhere near what he saw in the exhibitions.
The game will speed up in his mind so quickly, he will be
overwhelmed unless, of course, I have seriously misjudged him and Shurmur and
Childress prove to be correct in their assessment.
Word is Shurmur is making this decision because he intends
to give the offensive line the night off and doesn’t want Weeden working with
the second unit.
However, that starting unit has performed rather poorly thus
far and needs the work. And it is getting the night off as a reward.
Some coaching decisions puzzle. This one totally baffles.
Monday, August 27, 2012
Give Weeden a chance
If he’s smart – and the jury is still out on that – Pat
Shurmur will give Brandon Weeden plenty of reps in Thursday night’s exhibition
finale against the Chicago Bears.
Yes, I know the final exhibition means play your starters
for a series, maybe two, then allow them to watch the rest of the game from the
sidelines. Something about saving them for the regular season and not leaving
them open to injuries.
That, of course, is negative thinking, something with which
I am somewhat familiar. But I’m not a football coach. And I don’t play one on
the Internet.
But if Weeden does not play at least one half of the Bears
exhibition, he will be woefully unprepared for the regular-season opener against
the Philadelphia Eagles Sept. 9 at Cleveland Browns Stadium.
Unless Shurmur and offensive coordinator Brad Childress have
been keeping their money-counts offense under wraps for strategic reasons,
their rookie quarterback will unfairly get the rudest of welcomes to the National
Football League.
Weeden, who has yet to take a snap in the second half of a
game, has learned next to nothing during the exhibition season other than
realizing ball security is paramount if you have the remotest chance of winning
a game.
He needs as much work as he can get before the games become
meaningful. And his exhibition statistics back up that notion. Let’s take a
look.
In the first three exhibitions, Weeden has thrown 49 passes
and completed 24 for 297 yards, one interception and no touchdowns. In 17 series (one of them
just one play), he has produced just one touchdown (on the ground) and five
field goals. He has been sacked four times in six quarters and fumbled three
times, losing two.
Not exactly the kind of stats you’d want your quarterback to
have entering the regular season. If he was a veteran with those numbers, no
problem. But he’s a wet-behind-the-ears rookie who has no idea what awaits beginning
with the Eagles.
He might think he’s ready. And Shurmur might think he’s
ready. He’s not even close, and
failing to give him significant reps against the Bears will be more detrimental
than helpful.
With few exceptions, the coaching staff has tied Weeden’s
hands. Rarely does he throw the long ball. What’s wrong with stretching the
field to loosen up opposing defenses? Could it be the coaches have deemed the
offensive starters not ready, thus dumbing down the attack?
Right now, those starters are playing embarrassingly bad
football. Sort of like what we’ve witnessed the last four years of Browns
football on that side of the ball during the regular season. Very offensive.
Perhaps Shurmur and Childress are being extra cautious
because Weeden is a rookie. If that’s the case, then sit him down and let Colt
McCoy start. Handling Weeden with kid gloves is not the right way.
He needs to be thrown into the fire with as much ammunition
as the coaches can provide. Let him make mistakes. As long as they are mistakes
of aggression, that’s OK. But mistakes due to timid coaching are inexcusable.
Not to worry, though. Shurmur and Childress can be counted
on play it vest-close against the Bears. Same old, same old.
Only the faces change.
Saturday, August 25, 2012
Message received?
Andy Reid sent his buddy Part Shurmur a message Friday night
at Cleveland Browns Stadium.
Basically, the Philadelphia coach told the Cleveland coach
that the Eagles’ manhandling of the Browns in the third exhibition game of the
season was nothing compared to what it’s going to be like on Sept. 9 at the
same venue.
That’s when the two clubs open the regular season and Reid’s
Eagles will be faster, quicker and much nastier when the games become
meaningful.
The Browns played more like a team looking for a personality
against the much more experienced Eagles in the 27-10 loss. The Eagles found
their personality under Reid a long time ago.
Shurmur, who served as an assistant with the Eagles several
years ago, didn’t even come close to preparing his men properly for this one.
Philadelphia was at least a step and a half ahead of Cleveland all evening.
How else can you account for three fumbles, a couple of
interceptions, a blocked punt and a rash of penalties? Does that sound like a
prepared team?
Yes, I know it was just an exhibition game. But at least
play some representative football. Look like a football team. Do the things you
plan on doing during the regular season.
Like tackle. Like run good pass routes. Like play smart
football. And that’s just the beginning.
Is that asking too much? With this team, maybe it is. The
word “discipline” does not appear in this team’s vocabulary. Yet.
Another fumble by Brandon Weeden. Another fumble by Montario
Hardesty, who claim he hasn’t fumbled since high school. Another strip sack of
Weeden, courtesy of a porous offensive line.
“We turned the ball over,” said Captain Obvious Shurmur
after the game. “We gave up big plays. We did find a way to drive the ball, but
you can’t turn it over.”
No kidding.
“All of the things that you can’t do we found a way to do,”
he lamented. “It’s not good enough.”
Here it is the end of the exhibition season and Shurmur is
already beginning to sound like Eric Mangini and Romeo Crennel.
Asked whether he was concerned about his team, he said,
“Hold the concern and worry questions. I’m not disappointed or concerned. We’re
going to get it fixed (very Mangini and Crennel). We can beat anybody, but we
don’t play well, we can get beat by anybody.”
Quite profound.
The Browns can ill afford to gift opponents as they did the
Eagles. They cannot make even the slightest mistake because they’re not good
enough to recover from them.
For example, marching down to the Eagles’ 2-yard- line in
the first quarter, only to commit a holding penalty (yeah you, Jason Pinkston) on
first-and-goal and then give up a strip sack of Weeden (yeah you again, Jason
Pinskton).
Granted the defense worked with short fields on the first
two Philly TDs, but red-zone defense was one of their strengths last season. They
also made Eagles rookie quarterback Nick Foles look like a seasoned veteran.
Weeden, still looking for his first touchdown pass, is
playing with shackles, throwing downfield just twice. He hit Josh Gordon on the
game’s opening play and overthrew Travis Benjamin late in the second quarter.
What are Shurmur and offensive coordinator Brad Childress
waiting for? Time to loosen up opposing defenses. If it was Shurmur’s intention
to play vanilla football against the Eagles because the two teams meet again in
two weeks, it worked.
The result was a hammering, a beatdown that sent the aforementioned
message. If you think this was bad, wait until Sept. 9 when we take the speed
and quickness and nastiness up a few more notches.
I wonder what the Browns will bring to that game. Based on
what we saw this time around, it can’t be anything worse.
It might be not be a bad idea to watch tapes of this
drubbing and concentrate on the Eagles to learn the proper way to rush the
passer, protect the quarterback and develop a mean streak.
Couldn’t hurt.
Wednesday, August 22, 2012
Pressure cooker
It appears as though the pressures of the Browns’ training camp are getting to an unsuspecting victim.
During a 7-on-7 drill in Wednesday’s practice, quarterback Brandon Weeden connected on a long pass with wide receiver Travis Benjamin, who was dragged down from behind by cornerback Joe Haden.
Haden reached between the 8 and zero on the back of Benjamin’s uniform and yanked him down. The rookie wideout, who missed the second exhibition game with an undisclosed injury, bounced right back up and jogged to the huddle. End of story, right? Uh, no.
Coach Pat Shurmur immediately scolded Haden on what he probably considered a rough tackle and the two exchanged unpleasantries within hearing distance of the crowd on the last day of open practice to the public. The coach then dismissed the Haden for the rest of the practice.
It was not a horse-collar tackle, which would have drawn a flag in a game. It was a clean play that resulted in no harm and Shurmur clearly overreacted when he saw Benjamin, who missed the second exhibition game with an undisclosed injury, go down that way.
It’s one thing to be protective of a player coming back from injury. It’s quite another to engage in disharmony with one of your best players in front of the fans.
Following the practice. Shurmur refused to discuss the contretemps. ESPN Cleveland reporter Tony Grossi reported the coach got testy when the subject was broached.
“I’m not going to talk about it,” Shurmur said when asked what had happened “That’s between me and the player. I have a great deal of respect for Joe. If you want details, you’re going to have to find it on Twitter.”
Flippant remarks like do not sit well with the media, let alone the media’s constituents, the fans.
“My only apology is that I used bad language, and the fans were here to see it,” Shurmur said. “Joe’s a great competitor and I appreciate what he does and who he is and that’s the last you’ll hear me talk about it.”
A follow-up question was met with a brusque response. “Don’t ask,” the coach warned. “Don’t ask . . . You’ll have to go somewhere else to find out.”
The team, not surprisingly, shut off all communication with Haden, denying any and all media requests.
Fact is Shurmur lost control. It’s one thing for players to lose it in practice – fights are fairly commonplace during training camp – and quite another for someone on the coaching staff to lose it, let alone the head coach.
Haden returned to the field for the afternoon walk-through session. Shurmur later said that “Joe and I talked and everything’s fine. It’s a dead issue.”
It might be a dead issue in Shurmur’s mind, and maybe Haden’s, but you can bet it got the attention of the other members of the team. They saw their head coach lose it. One veteran, however, said he understood Shurmur’s reaction and blamed Haden.
“It was a mistake (Haden) did, but I don’t think he did it on purpose,” tight end Ben Watson told reporters. “You want everybody healthy for the season. You don’t want things like that to happen.”
Of course not, but you also don’t want to see your head coach totally overreact, especially after watching Benjamin bounce back obviously unhurt.
A quiet private talk with Haden following the practice would have been a much better way to handle the situation instead of embarrassing one of the team’s best players in front of the fans and his teammates.
Often times, common sense trumps emotional reactions. This should have been one of those times.
Monday, August 20, 2012
A second dress rehearsal
OK, let me see if I’ve got this straight.
The Browns, at least according to coach Pat Shurmur, played
their dress-rehearsal game last Thursday in Green Bay against the Packers.
So far, so good.
This Friday night at Cleveland Browns Stadium, the Browns welcome
the Philadelphia Eagles in their third exhibition game of the season.
Check.
Eagles coach Andy Reid, however, says that since it’s his
club’s third exhibition, he’s going to play his regulars for at least a half because
it’s their dress-rehearsal game.
Shurmur originally indicated game two in Green Bay was the
dress rehearsal for the regular season because the Browns and Eagles open the
regular season just 16 days after meeting in Friday’s exhibition.
Now comes word from Berea that Shurmur has rethought the
situation and Cleveland’s ones most likely will play as long as the Eagles’
starters.
Reid has put his former assistant coach on the spot, but he
can’t worry about that. He wants to get his men ready for the regular season
and this just happens to be the third exhibition game. Call it inconvenient
scheduling.
Question is how vanilla will the calls be for the Browns in this one on
both sides of the ball? In the first two exhibitions, Shurmur and offensive
coordinator Brad Childress played the conservative card. Heavily.
There is every reason to believe the Browns will stress
fundamentals in this one and exercise extreme caution. On offense, we most
likely will see a lot more off tackle runs and short passes. On defense, mostly
straight up. Nothing fancy. Don’t want to give away too much.
The Browns have more to lose by opening up the playbooks on offense
and defense since their talent level is nowhere near that of the more explosive
Eagles, who probably will be much more daring.
So Shurmur’s plan of just one dress rehearsal has now morphed
into a couple. And that’s not a bad thing. The more reps the starters get
between now and the season opener, the better. This is a young offense that
needs all the work it can get.
So it very well could turn out to be somewhat of a blessing
in disguise for the Browns if Reid plays his strong hand. Considering Brandon
Weeden has yet to throw his first touchdown pass – and his receivers haven’t
exactly been scintillating in running their routes – this extra work cannot hurt.
But there is one certainty that will emerge from Friday
night’s meeting. The Eagles’ defense Weeden sees in no way will bear any
resemblance to the one he sees on Sept. 9 at CBS. That’s when the tempo of the game changes radically. The
speed and quickness of the game shift dramatically when the meaningful games
begin.
Friday, August 17, 2012
A Weeden metamorphosis
It has become more than obvious that Browns coach Pat
Shurmur and offensive coordinator Brad Childress are determined to turn Brandon
Weeden into a pro-set quarterback.
In the Browns’ 35-10 victory over Green Bay Thursday night,
the rookie quarterback took 39 snaps in what Shurmur labeled the dress
rehearsal for the regular season. An incredible 31 of those snaps, or roughly 80%, saw Weeden under center Alex Mack.
Why is that so incredible? And what’s the big deal?
Before taking his first snap under center during OTAs this
past spring, Weeden was a shotgun quarterback. Lining up seven yards behind the
center and latching on to a sailing snap was his comfort level. That’s all he
knew.
At Oklahoma State University and at Santa Fe High School in Edmond, Okla., the ball slapping against his hands on a direct snap from the
center was foreign to him. His view of opposing defenses was anything but up
close and personal.
All that is changing now with the Browns. We are witnessing
a transformation, a reinvention, so to speak.
Weeden is used to that. The reason he became the 22nd
pick in the first round of last April’s college football draft was because he
reinvented himself as a football player after a failed pro baseball career.
And if anyone can make the switch with seamless ease, it’s
Weeden. Watching him make his three-, five- and seven-step drops against the
Packers in effortless fashion, one would guess he’s been doing it his whole
career at all levels.
It’s much easier taking a shotgun snap and surveying the
field. More time for the receivers to get open, more time for the offensive
line to pass protect, more time to be successful.
And yet, there was the force-fed Weeden making plays from
the pro set. Not once did he stumble back after taking the snap from Mack. Not
once did his feet become entangled as he set up to throw. He made no apparent
mistakes.
He threw no interceptions, even though one should have been
picked off, and was not sacked, although Packers cornerback Brandian Ross
nailed him hard in the ribs late in the first half a split second after
releasing a pass.
He completed 12 of his 20 passes (would have been 14 if not
for two drops) for 118 yards on five drives, not including the first drive when
Montario Hardesty fumbled away the ball on the first play of the game, and the
last drive with just seconds remaining in the first half.
Of the eight shotgun snaps, all were passes. That’s got to
change. Otherwise, it becomes predictable. Some run plays need to be used from
the formation.
Five shotgun passes were on third down with three
completions, none resulting in a first down. Half of the eight shotgun snaps
occurred late in the half when the Browns ran the two-minute drill.
Other than that, Weeden looked extremely comfortable. That’s
because he’s a good athlete who seems to have very good pocket awareness,
something you can’t teach.
Whether or not it was by design, he rarely threw downfield.
Stretching the field was not in this game plan. He’s got a strong arm. Use it.
Keep opposing defenses honest. That might not happen, though, with a
play-calling head coach who leans toward the conservative side.
* * *
Much like last
season, the Browns are relying too much on the field goal. The offense
scored just two touchdowns against the Packers. That’s not enough. If that
trend continues, we could see a replication of last season when the club
averaged just 13.6 points a game.
When Phil Dawson is your best offensive threat, you’re in
trouble, although you can’t quarrel with field goals of 53, 47 and 52 yards. His
56-yard attempt sailed wide in the closing seconds of the first half. The guy’s
not Superman.
Still, Shurmur and Childress have to be able to give the
offense a better chance to put points on the board while Dawson watches from
the sidelines. The veteran placekicker would like nothing better than to add to
his extra-point total.
* * *
If Colt McCoy was
trying to impress scouts from other National Football League teams in his
brief stint against the Packers, he succeeded. The kid from Texas maximized his
one-series appearance, taking seven minutes and 22 seconds off the clock with a
near-flawless 14-play, 75-yard drive in the third quarter. He was 4-of-6
passing, including strikes of 19 yards to Josh Gordon and 21 yards to Dan
Gronkowski.
That has to impress Shurmur and his staff. Question is
whether the Browns hope to use that showing as a springboard for a trade, or
will it convince them that holding on to McCoy is the road better traveled.
The way Packers backup quarterback Graham Harrell played
against the Browns, it wouldn’t be surprising if Green Bay is thinking about
knocking on the Browns’ door. Or maybe the Arizona Cardinals, who have
experienced quarterback problems.
* * *
It’s nice to see the
defense show up against the Packers, although their regulars played just
three series. Still, you can’t quarrel with four turnovers, one pick six and a
run defense that limited Green Bay to a paltry 69 yards. Subtract Aaron
Rodgers’ 24 yards on a couple of scrambles and the Packers compiled just 45
yards on 16 carries. And that was with veterans Ahtyba Rubin and D’Qwell Jackson
on the sidelines.
* * *
Other observations: The
defense was unusually active pre-snap against the Packers, giving Rodgers and
Harrell many different looks. . . . Hardesty redeemed himself nicely after the
opening-play fumble with some hard running. If he can stay healthy, and that’s
a huge if, the Browns are in good shape at running back. . . . That’s two weeks
in a row now that safety David Sims has made a spectacular interception. His
38-yard pick six early in the third quarter gave the Browns a 23-7 lead. . . .
Fellow defensive back Trevin Wade had another strong game. The rookie is not
afraid to stick his nose in there on run support. . . . Browns offensive tackle
Oneil Cousins should be ex-Browns offensive tackle Oneil Cousins after his
performance on special teams. He racked up 25 of the Browns’ 67 penalty yards,
once on a hold and the other a facemask. Both were on placements. . . . Unless
the Browns are willing to overpay his salary for his special teams contribution
as a gunner, it’s hard to see Joshua Cribbs sticking around. Based on early
returns, Cribbs is no longer a threat on punt and kickoff returns. And it’s already
a foregone conclusion by most fans that he is not a reliable wide receiver.
Monday, August 13, 2012
Flawed thinking
So the Browns, really coach Pat Shurmur, have decided that
Thursday night’s exhibition game in Green Bay, their second practice game of the
season, will serve as the club’s dress rehearsal for the regular season.
Generally, the third game of the exhibition season is
considered the dress rehearsal with the starters playing at least one half and
sometimes the first series of the second half.
But since the Browns’ third exhibition opponent is the
Philadelphia Eagles, with whom they open the regular season on Sept. 9, that
game will be handled personnel-wise like the fourth game. In other words,
starters play one of two series and then sit.
Which makes one wonder just how the coaching staff will
handle the final exhibition against the Chicago Bears. It makes that one that
much more intriguing.
So let’s recap. The dress rehearsal has been moved up to
exhibition game No. 2 for the starters with just three series (14 snaps) under
their belts. And that’ll pretty much be it until the season opener against the
Eagles.
All of which means the starters will not see significant
game action between Aug. 16 (this Thursday) and Sept. 9. That’s 24 days between
meaningful snaps for the starters.
Is that any way to begin a season, especially one filled
with such hope now that the club has been sold and there’s new blood flowing in
Berea?
Who’s in charge here? How in the world did this happen? And
what difference does it make when the so-called dress rehearsal game is played?
Is Mike Holmgren on vacation? Where does he stand on this
matter? His silence is deafening. Does he agree with this move? As a former
coach, he knows the importance of being ready for the regular season. He knows
24 days is too long to keep an offense under wraps.
In this case, it makes much more sense to schedule the dress
rehearsal gig for the fourth game against the Bears on Sept. 1, eight full days
before the season opener. That way, there can be no doubt the team will be as ready
as it can be.
As it stands now, if Shurmur and his staff stubbornly refuse
to budge from their stance, the Browns will enter the season as the most
unprepared team in the National Football League. The rigid approach most likely
will burn them.
A rookie quarterback learning a new system and working from
a position (under center) that is foreign to him with limited snaps is not the prescription you
want to enter a season. Brandon Weeden needs to get plenty of reps before the
speed and quickness of the game ramp up. He won’t get them this way.
Again, if Shurmur does not change his strategy, he will be
doing his offense a huge disservice. At the risk of being repetitive, offense
is all about rhythm and timing, and the only way to hone that is by getting as
many reps as possible.
Where is the common sense here? Just because it says the
dress rehearsal must be the third game (of the four exhibitions played) doesn’t
mean it has to be moved up rather than moved back.
Does Shurmur really want to send Weeden and his offense onto
the field against the Eagles on Sept. 9 with just a handful of exhibition snaps? And 24
days between meaningful football?
Apparently he does. That kind of thinking brings back memories
of Romeo Crennel.
‘Nuf said.
Sunday, August 12, 2012
A decent start
Observations while
watching the Browns get off to a good start (at least on the scoreboard) in
exhibition season . . .
First of all, notice I call these practice games
exhibitions, not preseason games even though they are games played before the
regular season, which technically makes them preseason.
For some reason, the haughty National Football League does
not like to use the term “exhibition” when labeling these meaningless games.
And yet, that’s exactly what they are: exhibitions.
Maybe the league feels guilty for charging regular-season
ticket prices for these outings and by calling them preseason games, it takes
the sting out of charging so flagrantly.
Now then, the 19-17 exhibition victory Friday night in
Detroit.
* * *
Pat Shurmur and Brad Childress did not see enough of Brandon
Weeden and the first-string offense to come away with a definitive judgment.
That unit should have played more than the first three series. Much more.
Granted it was just the first exhibition of the season, but
there are only four of these games and the final one, for some stupid reason,
has become a platform to configure the bottom part of the roster. In that final
game, most coaches rest the regulars for fear of exposing them to injuries.
That, of course, is nonsensical since football is a
collision sport rife with injuries. And for that reason, that game becomes a
momentum killer for the starters, especially for young teams like the Browns.
It’s not like these Browns are seasoned veterans and don’t
need much work to get ready. This is a virtually remade offense that needs all
the work it can get to be sure the timing is ready in time for the season
opener.
Weeden, his receivers and his offensive line need to get in
more than three series (14 snaps) if they want to be ready to roll when the
games begin to take on meaning. And playing just a relative handful of plays is
not going to accomplish that goal.
With a young offense, the more plays you can run, the better
chance that offense has of cutting down on mistakes. It’s not like Weeden needs
just a couple of series to get used to the banging again.
The mistake most coaches make with rookies, especially those
ticketed to start right away, is not giving them enough reps to hone their
craft. Let them make their mistakes and then learn from them. The more reps,
the more mistakes and more chances to correct those mistakes.
Look for that group to play most of the first half of
Thursday’s exhibition in Green Bay and then play into the third quarter of the exhibition
against Philadelphia on Aug. 24 in Cleveland, the so-called dress rehearsal
for the regular season. And that poses another dilemma.
The Browns open the season at home Sept. 9 against the
Eagles, roughly two weeks after the exhibition against them on the same field.
How buttoned down will the Cleveland offense be in that exhibition as a result?
How can Weeden & Co. make any progress that way in that dress rehearsal?
Weeden and his men must get as many reps as possible
before the season opener. They need to be sharp. They won’t be if they watch a
majority of the exhibition season from the bench.
Unless Shurmur and Childress wise up and force-feed this
offense in the next three exhibitions, the Eagles will find their season opener
much easier than anticipated.
* * *
Unless the Browns increase their team speed on both sides of
the ball, this is going to be another long season. With the exception of rookie
wide receiver Travis Benjamin, there is no appreciable speed on offense.
And the defense seemed a step slow against Detroit. The
Lions’ running game piled up nearly 200 yards against the young Cleveland front
seven. Sure veterans Ahtyba Rubin and D’Qwell Jackson didn’t play, but it was
alarming to watch the Lions open up significant holes.
OK, it was just the first exhibitions and the players were
getting their game legs. So were the Lions, though, and they didn’t seem to
have much trouble with the Cleveland defense.
Weeden, on the other hand, had what can charitably be called
an uneven game. He showed surprising dexterity running the offense from under
center, something he has done little of in his football career. He’s an athlete
and it showed.
His three- and five-step drops were flawless and he made
quick decisions, a few of which were incorrect. For someone who played in the
spread his entire college career, he also showed dexterity in the play-action fake
while operating under center.
It’ll be interesting to see whether Childress incorporates
seven-step drops into Weeden’s repertoire. When Trent Richardson returns and
the running game takes shape, the rookie quarterback’s play-faking ability
should come in handy and be effective.
Weeden seems smart enough where he can correct his errors
before others surface. That’s how you learn to play quarterback in the NFL.
* * *
Other observations: As long as the coaches keep Benjamin
away from the middle of the field, he should be all right. The slight wideout
also showed nice hands on his two receptions. . . . Weeden, at times, made the
rookie mistake of locking onto his primary target. It resulted in his
interception. He has to look off his primary. He would have had two picks had
Dwight Bentley not dropped an earlier one. . . . Before he left with a back
injury, second-year tight end Jordan Cameron impressed with two nice catches. .
. . Rookie offensive tackle Mitchell Schwartz will not forget his opening series
as a pro. He was flagged for a false start on a third and 10 at the Detroit 23,
then gave up a strip sack to Detroit defensive end Willie Young that resulted
in a turnover. . . . Mo Massaquoi should retire before he is seriously injured.
The veteran wideout, who has had two concussions the last two seasons, caught
the first pass of Weeden’s pro career on the Browns’ first offensive play of
the evening, then left the game with another concussion. . . . Good sign: Safety
T.J. Ward is back healthy and starting to hit people. . . . Rookie cornerback
Trevin Wade replaced the injured Dimitri Patterson and did not play like a
rookie, showing the willingness to stick his head in there on run support and
making nice plays in the passing game. . . . Punter Reggie Hodges, back after
missing the 2011 season, appeared in mid-season form, dropping a couple of
punts inside the 10-yard line. . . . Nice pick by veteran corner Sheldon Brown
in the first quarter off Matthew Stafford. . . . And a great pick by David Sims
in the final seconds to seal the victory.
Tuesday, August 7, 2012
Nothing more than a blip?
Well that was quick.
Just when Browns fans were in a can’t-wait-for-the-exhibition-season-to-begin
mode, bad news hits them like a sledgehammer.
The Browns announced Tuesday that rookie running back Trent
Richardson’s left knee is sore and he might miss Friday night’s exhibition
opener in Detroit against the Lions.
Great. The club’s top draft choice and the guy many expect
to be a major factor in the club’s offensive comeback this season lands on the
injury chart.
This might be nothing more than an overreaction, but for
once, I’d like to see this team experience some good luck. Why couldn’t a
third-string defensive back go down? Or someone who has as much chance of
making the club as you and I.
Why the biggest name, the guy who has a chance to become the
face of the franchise? The one player who can really make a difference.
On the brighter side, perhaps this might be nothing more
than a cautionary move. Let’s err on the side of being certain it’s nothing
more than soreness related to his arthroscopic surgery to repair a torn
meniscus six months ago.
A pessimist might think this is just the beginning, the tip
of the injury iceberg for Richardson. Next up will be the meniscus on his other
knee. Then an ACL or MCL or both. Look what happened to Montario Hardesty.
An optimist would think it’s better to make certain
Richardson is perfectly healthy for the season opener rather than risk further
injury during the exhibition season.
When it comes to a player like Richardson, who arrives in
the National Football League with more fanfare than any running back since
Adrian Peterson, fans almost froth at what he could accomplish if he stays
healthy.
Running backs take more pounding than any other player on
offense. It’s not unreasonable for the Browns to make certain he is as close to
100% as possible for the 16-game grind.
For a player who has the reputation of being a terrific
runner, above-average receiver out of the backfield and a devastating blocker, he
needs to be on the field for every one of those games.
Yes, I know other clubs suffer as a result of injuries to
key players. It just seems as though it happens more to the Browns than other
clubs. Some fans will lament that someone up there doesn’t like their favorite
football team.
Hopefully, it’s nothing more than scar-tissue adhesions
providing the soreness and Richardson will be ready to strut before the schedule
for games that mean nothing ends.
It looks as though the fans will have to wait a little
longer to see the kid. Which, when you stop and think about it, might not be so
bad. Good things await those who wait. And what Richardson can deliver is one
of those good things definitely worth waiting for.
As long as nothing more serious happens to the rookie between
now and the Sept. 9 season opener against the Philadelphia Eagles at Cleveland
Browns Stadium, this latest little blip on the radar will be just that – a little
blip.
Monday, August 6, 2012
Of course it's Weeden
Brandon Weeden named starting quarterback for the Cleveland
Browns.
Shocking. Absolutely shocking.
What in the world is Pat Shurmur thinking? Has he lost his
senses? Has he no respect for Colt McCoy? Or Seneca Wallace?
Naming a rookie who has never taken a snap as a professional
as the starting quarterback even before he takes his first snap as a
professional? Unheard of. Blasphemous.
OK, enough with the sarcasm. Time to get serious.
Speaking of getting serious, what took Shurmur so long to do
what many of us expected him to do the day after Weeden was drafted? What in
the world was he waiting for?
Did he expect McCoy to develop arm strength? Or Wallace to
gain three inches in height?
Any way you cut it, this is the correct decision. Shurmur’s
job depends on how well Weeden and his young offense performs this season. In
many ways, Weeden is Shurmur’s lifeline.
It’s incumbent on the head coach and offensive coordinator Brad
Childress to shepherd the 28-year-old rookie through the third-toughest
schedule in the National Football League.
It won’t be easy. There will be numerous rough spots along
the 16-game schedule. The highs will be inordinately high and the lows will be
depressingly low. That’s to be expected, even anticipated.
Naming Weeden the starter now removes any and all doubts
that might have existed in the locker room. Everyone now knows who the boss of
the huddle will be. They know their fortunes ride on his strong arm.
Offense is all about finesse and rhythm, especially in the
passing game. The more Weeden and his offensive line and receivers work
together in practice, the sharper they should be in games. Precise timing is
essential.
So all the pressure is off now. Or is it?
Up until now, who would start at quarterback was a guessing game, although
it had to be in the back of Weeden’s mind he’d be named the starter. If
anything, his confidence level has risen with each practice.
The question is how will McCoy handle being Weeden’s
caddy? He had to know the deck was stacked against him. He has acted in a
professional manner in training camp, saying all the right things. But one has to wonder how
much longer he’ll be satisfied to play that role.
Wallace is an entirely different matter. He says he would be
upset if he was the No. 3 quarterback on the roster. Fact is he’s just hanging
on and is happy to be on an NFL roster.
The way McCoy is throwing in camp, not many tears would be
shed if Wallace wound up in another uniform this season. Add to that McCoy’s friendly contract
and perhaps that’s the road the Browns should travel.
I’d much rather have McCoy come off the bench than Wallace
in the event of an injury or a blowout.
But for right now, Weeden is the man. He’s the quarterback
of the present and future. And that’s the way it should be.
Maybe, just maybe, he’ll perform as well as another
28-year-old rookie in the NFL a long time ago. That’s how old Roger Staubach was when he took
over the Dallas Cowboys in 1970. And we all know where his bust resides.
Sunday, August 5, 2012
The prescient GM
Tom Heckert Jr. must have suspected something when he
selected a couple of linebackers in last April’s college football draft.
The Browns’ general manager knew he was going to lose Scott
Fujita for three games at the beginning of the season due to the New Orleans
Saints bounty scandal. But he never would have guessed what happened to Chris
Gocong the other day.
When the veteran outside linebacker’s right Achilles’ tendon
ruptured in a non-contact play Saturday and short-circuited his 2012 season, the
Browns’ least talented position was dealt a severe blow.
The Browns have veteran depth at just about every other
position on the team. Linebacker was where they could least afford an injury.
But that’s where Heckert’s prescient ways come into play.
Who knew when he drafted James-Michael Johnson and Emmanuel Acho that those two
would play a vital role this season?
Heckert apparently did.
Gocong’s unfortunate injury could very well pay off for the
two rookie linebackers, who put up significant numbers in college. Whether that
translates well to the National Football League is, of course, an entirely
different matter.
But if there’s one position on the team that college players
have an easier time assimilating to in the pro ranks, it’s linebacker. Especially
if that’s a position they’ve played on a full-time basis.
Johnson, a tackling machine at the University of Nevada,
comes in with a reputation as a ball magnet. Some say the ball finds him, but
more likely he finds the ball. He always seemed to be around the ball at
Nevada.
And if Acho can duplicate the accomplishments of older
brother Sam, who emerged as a starting linebacker as a rookie last season with
the Arizona Cardinals, he could be something special. He’s lighter (240 pounds to Sam’s 260), but owns the
same football instincts.
Right now, Browns defensive coordinator Dick Jauron is relying on
Kaluka Maiava to fill the hole created by Gocong’s injury. But Maiava’s size is
a mitigating factor. He’s not big enough (5-11, 230) or strong enough to help
the run game, which needs all the help it can get.
His work ethic cannot be questioned. But the results fall
far short of expectations and that’s where Jauron has to decide if gambling on
a couple of rookies is the way to go.
If that proves too much of a gamble for Heckert, the only
other route to travel is the waiver wire, where the pickings are thin. Veterans
Stephen Cooper, Kevin Bentley, Gary Hackett, E. J, Henderson, Ernie Sims Jr.
and Matt Roth are out there. But those street free agents arrive with some sort
of baggage.
The best of the lot might be Roth, who logged a productive
season and a half with the Browns before opting to jump to Jacksonville last
season. The outside linebacker preferred to play in the Jaguars’ 3-4 scheme
after the Browns converted to a 4-3. Then the Jags released him after switching
to the 4-3.
No one has expressed interest in him so far and you have to
wonder if he’ll acquiesce and play OLB for a 4-3 team. At 6-4, 275, he could be
valuable in the run defense.
Cooper might be the next best bet if he has recovered from
injuries that virtually wiped out his 2011 season. He’s 33 years old now and
that could be a negative factor, but he’s smart enough to hold down one of
the outside positions until next season, when Gocong will return.
Heckert no doubt is scrambling to shore up the linebacker
roster. Excluding Fujita, Maiava and veteran D’Qwell Jackson, Quinton Spears is
the only backup on the roster with more than one NFL season. He has two as a
reserve.
Panic time? Not really. With an offense expected to far
exceed the accomplishments of last season’s team, Heckert knows that the
defense, while it might not exceed the achievements of last season, won’t be
in as much trouble so long as the offense can score.
Nevertheless, the GM won’t stop trying to strengthen that vital
area. But you can bet it’ll be high on his priority list for next year’s draft.
Provided he’s still here with the new ownership.
Had to put in that caveat because in the business world, you
never know what’s going to happen with a new ownership.
Saturday, August 4, 2012
A good beginning
After watching the new owner of the Browns in action Friday,
one adjective immediately leaps to mind.
Impressive.
After his roughly 25-minute debut news conference with the
Cleveland media, one gets the feeling Jimmy Haslam III is the kind of owner fans
of this team have hungered for the last 13 years.
Displaying a supremely confident air, Haslam fielded
questions like someone who has no problem addressing a large group. He was
relaxed, friendly and extremely poised.
If first impressions mean anything, Browns fans around the
globe are in for a screeching turnaround in the fortunes of this formerly
dysfunctional team. Unless he’s a con man, Haslam appears to be everything
Randy Lerner is not.
That’s not intended to be mean, although one can understand
it might be taken that way. Lerner was a reluctant owner after taking over the
team following the untimely death of his father in 2002. He guarded his privacy
zealously.
When you’re the owner of a National Football League team, however, you are automatically thrust upon a gigantic stage. Lerner was uncomfortable on
that stage. He and the spotlight were strangers.
Haslam, on the other hand, can’t wait to take over the team.
Judging from his first exposure to the Cleveland media, he relishes being on
that stage.
He answered all questions with the aplomb of someone who has
been doing it his entire life. He deftly and politely deflected those few
questions better answered by someone else. The southern gentleman was smooth
and downright charming.
Several times throughout the news conference, Haslam praised
the person asking the question by preceding his answer with “that’s a great
question” or “that’s a good question.” That’s a nice trick of making the
persons asking the question feel good about themselves.
Nothing wrong with it, of course, but that shows the savvy
that has helped him rise in the business world.
The Browns need someone strong at the top. Someone who can
come in, establish the proper culture and make certain every man is doing his
job. It has become painfully obvious over the last 13 years that aspect has
been absent.
Haslam, who has known nothing but success in his
professional life, appears to be that kind of individual. “Our style is we’re
going to be involved,” he said. “You’ll find we’re going to be open and
transparent. We’re going to be there selling the Cleveland Browns all the
time.”
Look for the new boss to be much more involved and proactive
than Lerner. “The most important decisions we make are going to be the people
we surround ourselves with,” he said. “Who you surround yourself with is very,
very important.”
He went on to call himself “a big believer in collective wisdom. If you have five smart
people around a table, it’s better than four.”
Unlike Lerner, whose football interest seems more rooted in
England, American football is a huge part of Haslam’s life. “We’ve been around
football all our lives,” he said.
As the highly successful CEO of Flying J truck stops all
around the country, it’s easy to see Haslam is used to winning. It’ll be
interesting to see how he handles the losing culture that has gripped this
franchise since the return in 1999.
Having been a minority investor in the Pittsburgh Steelers
for the last four years, the new Cleveland owner is well aware of the rivalry
that exists between the two franchises.
“I get the rivalry between Pittsburgh and Cleveland,” he
said. “Our main goal is to return that to a real rivalry.” It was an obvious
reference to the Steelers’ domination of the Browns since 1999.
In putting his stamp on his new toy, Haslam hinted that the
name of the stadium could change. The NFL’s only generic stadium name,
Cleveland Browns Stadium, could he history.
Ever the astute businessman, Haslam has to know that income
from stadium naming rights will not hurt the bottom line. Too bad. There’s
something about CBS that sets it apart from all the other corporate named
ballparks.
As do the Browns’ logo-less helmets. If there’s one thing
Haslam should keep his paws off, it’s the helmet. It is truly unique and sets
it apart from the rest of the league.
Change the uniform if you must, but leave the colors and
helmets alone. They are the last vestiges of what all Browns fans, young and
old, hold special.
Haslam’s ultimate goal, of course, is to turn the Browns
into a winning franchise. Maybe Lerner’s goal was the same. He just went about
it the wrong way for the last 10 years. That’s what happens when you surround yourself
with the wrong people.
Haslam, who plans to log plenty of air miles between homes
in Knoxville, Tenn., and the Cleveland area, is a welcome breath of fresh air. How
long it remains that way depends strictly on how he conducts business.
And, of course, how well the team responds to his stewardship.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)